Overview
Nancy Faggianelli represents business clients, financial institutions, and insurance companies in class actions and complex litigation in state and federal courts. She has substantial experience defending and prosecuting a wide variety of claims, including shareholder derivative claims, contractual disputes, securities claims, insurance coverage claims, product liability, infringement of intellectual property rights, misappropriation of trade secrets, professional liability, noncompetition agreements, and business torts.
Nancy has tried cases in the areas of breach of contract, insurance, infringement of intellectual property rights, defamation, employment discrimination, and product liability, and she has won injunctions in cases involving intellectual property rights, noncompetition agreements, and tortious interference with business relationships.
Nancy also has extensive experience in product liability cases, having tried two smoking and health cases for a major tobacco company, one of which was featured as the "Verdict of the Week" in the National Law Journal, and having defended over 20 other cases that were dismissed or resolved on summary judgment.
Nancy has devoted hundreds of pro bono hours to advancing LGBTQ+ rights, partnering with national civil rights organizations and other Carlton Fields lawyers on litigation that overturned Florida's ban on gay adoption, helped legalize same-sex marriage statewide, secured parental rights and adoption protections for LGBTQ+ families, protected LGBTQ+ students' right to organize in schools, and defended local bans on conversion therapy for minors.
Experience
Class Actions and MDL Representation
Defended consumer class action filed against an internet services company for violations of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act and the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act that settled after decertification.
Defended shareholder fraud class action in the insurance industry that settled after denial of class certification.
Defended a class action against a financial institution involving claims of breach of duty and aiding and abetting that was dismissed with prejudice and upheld on appeal.
Defended shareholder derivative class action regarding transactions between related insurance companies that settled after denial of class certification.
Appointment as liaison counsel for insurance agents across the country in MDL regarding sales practices of a major insurance company.
Representation of Financial Institutions
Defended financial institution in tax strategy litigation involving claims of fraud and breach of contract against financial institutions, accounting professionals, and attorneys.
Prosecution of professional liability claim against international accounting firm based on representations made to national bank to fund a billion-dollar acquisition.
Defended a national bank against claims of conspiracy, aiding and abetting, negligence, and breach of duties brought by the receiver of a depositor who had operated a massive Ponzi scheme.
Defended NASD arbitrations involving allegations of fraud, unsuitability, and other breaches by securities brokers.
Defended broker-dealers against claims by elderly person alleging improper management of investments.
Representation of Insurance Companies
Defended coverage actions involving various types of policies, including life insurance, property and casualty, and environmental coverage claims.
Defended more than 100 lawsuits alleging broker fraud and misconduct in a national MDL.
Defended multiple lawsuits alleging bad faith and intentional tortious conduct in the handling of workers' compensation claims.
Defended bad faith and breach of duty claims brought by shareholders.
Defended claims by elderly plaintiffs alleging that insurance agents misrepresented the benefits of using equity in existing policies to purchase additional policies.
Intellectual Property Matters
Landmark prosecution of claims against the state of Florida for the unconstitutional taking of property rights to a patented method to clean waterways.
Prosecution of litigation to enforce intellectual property rights transferred in the acquisition of a manufacturer of insulation products.
Prosecution of litigation to enforce intellectual property rights and noncompetition provision in acquisition agreements for international swimming pool products company.
Co-counsel and local counsel with national and international law firms in numerous patent infringement cases.
Trials and Appellate Representation
Jury trial in state court of claims that insurer committed intentional torts in handling plaintiff's workers' compensation claim, resulting in settlement before the conclusion of the defendant's case.
Jury trial in federal court of an employment discrimination claim based on alleged sexual harassment, resulting in a directed verdict.
Jury trial in federal court in product liability action involving water pipes used in rural communities throughout the Midwest, concluding in settlement before verdict.
Bench trial in state court involving claims of breach of contract and breach of fiduciary duty, resulting in a defense verdict.
Bench trial in state court involving claims of breach of contract and civil theft in connection with the acquisition of controlling shares of privately held corporation, resulting in a defense verdict.
Jury trial in federal court involving claims of defamation and age discrimination brought by former president of corporation who was, in fact, terminated for paying illegal kickbacks, resulting in a defense verdict.
Jury trials in state court involving smoking and health claims against a major tobacco company, resulting in one defense verdict and one plaintiff's verdict.
Bench trial in state court to enjoin foreclosure on a nationally franchised hotel resulting in an order enjoining foreclosure.
Bench trial in state court defending breach of contract claims concerning construction of the Tampa Bay Performing Arts Center.
Bench trials before administrative law judges regarding establishment of new automobile dealerships in Florida.
Bench trials in state court to terminate parental rights.
Appeals and oral arguments before the Florida Supreme Court, the Second District Court of Appeal, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit.
News & Insights
News
Publications
Speaking Engagements
"Equality Means Business: The Business Case For Diversity and Inclusion," Rotary Club of Tampa, Tampa, FL (June 4, 2019)
"Litigation and Dispute Resolution Management: Aligning Strategy, Budget and Support," Martindale-Hubbell Counsel to Counsel Forum, Chicago, IL (June 19, 2009)
"Bad Faith Claims," Association of Workers' Compensation Claims Professionals Leadership Conference, Naples, FL (2008)
Recognition
Honors & Recognitions
The Best Lawyers in America (2024–2027)
Legal Elite Notable Women Leaders in Law, Florida Trend (2026)
Diversity and Inclusion Award, Daily Business Review (2023)
Multicultural Leadership Award, Florida Diversity Council (2016)
LGBT-Allies Leader Award, Florida Diversity Council (2014)
Diversity Officer Leadership Award, Diversity Best Practices (2008)
No aspect of this advertisement has been approved by the highest court of any state. See Awards Methodology.
Professional & Community Involvement
Professional & Community Involvement
Nancy is a member of the American Bar Association's Litigation Section, including its Minority Trial Lawyer Committee. In the Florida Bar, she belongs to the Business Law Section's Business Litigation Committee and previously served on the Civil Procedure Rules Committee and its Electronic Discovery Subcommittee, chaired the Subcommittee on Rule 1.351, and twice chaired the Thirteenth Circuit Grievance Committee. She is also a member of the Hillsborough County Bar Association and Equality Florida, the state's largest LGBTQ civil rights organization. Previously, she served on the board of directors of the Federal Bar Association's Tampa Bay chapter, was a master of the Ferguson-White American Inn of Court, and was treasurer of the Hillsborough Association for Women Lawyers.
Beyond the Bio
Nancy has helped build the firm's culture of inclusion from within. As the firm's chief diversity officer, she created and led the firm's Gay and Lesbian Equality Network, now the LGBTQ+ Business Resource Group, and helped make Carlton Fields one of the first major Florida law firms to offer domestic partner benefits and, more recently, gender-affirming health care coverage. She has carried the same commitment into her pro bono work, devoting hundreds of hours to cases that have expanded the rights of LGBTQ+ families and students in Florida.
In her practice, Nancy handled the landmark prosecution of claims against the state of Florida for the unconstitutional taking of property rights to a patented method to clean waterways.
At the University of Florida College of Law, Nancy was inducted into the Order of the Coif and served as editor of the Florida Law Review.
Related Capabilities
Bar Admissions
Court Admissions
Education
J.D., with honors, University of Florida College of Law
B.A., University of Florida
